Prop companies vs. professional institutional traders. What’s the difference? – Others – January 14, 2024
Both individual (owned) corporate traders and professional/institutional traders actively participate in financial markets, but they differ significantly in terms of their roles, structures, and motivations.
Sole proprietorship traders:
- role: Sole traders, often called “free traders,” work in self-dealing companies. These companies use their own capital to trade financial instruments such as stocks, options, futures, and foreign exchange with the goal of making profits.
- Capital sources: Prop trading companies provide traders with capital in the company that they can trade on. Profits generated are usually shared between the trader and the company, with the trader receiving a percentage of the profits.
- Risk Profile: Prop traders are exposed to the company’s risk and their compensation is often tied to trading performance. If traders consistently generate profits, they can earn significant bonuses.
- autonomy: Prop traders often have more autonomy in their trading decisions than institutional traders. They may have specific strategies or markets they focus on and are responsible for the profitability of their trades.
Professional/Institutional Traders:
- role: Professional or institutional traders work for financial institutions such as banks, hedge funds, asset management firms, research institutes, pension funds, or other large financial institutions. Their main responsibilities are managing and investing client funds and doing trading for some institutions.
- Capital sources: Institutional traders trade using the institution’s capital or funds managed by the institution. They do not trade with personal funds or proprietary capital of a company.
- Risk Profile: Institutional traders are responsible for managing risk and achieving investment objectives set by the institution or its clients. Their compensation may include salary, bonuses, or a percentage of profits, depending on the structure of the employment or compensation agreement.
Regulatory Oversight: Institutional traders operate within a framework of regulatory oversight and their activities are often subject to financial regulations. They must adhere to risk management guidelines and comply with legal and regulatory requirements.
Key differences:
- Capital Sources and Risks: The main differences lie in the source of capital and risk exposure. Prop traders use the company’s capital and share profits with the company, while institutional traders manage external funds and follow specific investment mandates.
- autonomy: Prop traders often enjoy greater freedom in making trading decisions because they trade using the company’s capital. Institutional traders, on the other hand, may be required to adhere to specific investment strategies and guidelines set by the institution or fund they work for.
- Reward Structure: A prop trader’s compensation structure is often more directly tied to trading performance and the profits they generate, while institutional traders may have a more traditional salary and bonus structure.
In summary, both prop firm traders and professional/institutional traders engage in active trading, but their roles, capital sources, risk profiles and compensation structures are significantly different. Prop traders trade with the company’s money and share in the profits, while institutional traders manage external funds and are accountable to the organization or clients.
